Monday, July 23, 2012

REVIEW: No-Nonsense Algebra + Geometry Workbook from Math Essentials

I had the opportunity to review No-Nonsense Algebra as well as the Geometry Workbook by Math Essentials. 

First, let me tell you about No-Nonsense Algebra, which was the main product for this review.  With No-Nonsense Algebra, you get a workbook with lessons and practice and a code in the back of the book that you enter on the website in order to access free online video instruction for every lesson.  This is a complete Algebra I program and costs a mere $27.95.    

 From the Website:

No-Nonsense Algebra

Table of Contents

Chapter 1 Necessary Tools for Algebra
Chapter 2 Solving Equations
Chapter 3 Graphing and Analyzing Linear Equations
Chapter 4 Solving and Graphing Inequalities
Chapter 5 Systems of Linear Equations and Inequalities
Chapter 6 Polynomials
Chapter 7 Rational Expressions (Algebraic Fractions)
Chapter 8 Radical Expressions and Geometry
Chapter 9 Quadratic Equations
Chapter 10 Algebra Word Problems


Also included:

*A “How to Use This Book” Section

*Chapter reviews
*Final Exam
*Solutions for all Problems
*Glossary
*Resource Center


Each Easy-To-Understand Lesson Includes:

*       Each topic is clearly explained in a way that the student can easily understand.
*       A Helpful Hints section
*       Examples with simple step-by-step solutions
*       Written exercises
*       A short Review section that ensures that the student will remember what has been learned


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Includes
free online access to video instruction!
Each lesson in the book has a corresponding video lesson taught by America’s Math Teacher, Richard W. Fisher
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------


*       No Fluff!
*       No Distractions!
*       Short, concise self-contained lessons
*       Each topic is explained in way that the student can easily understand
*       Lots of examples with fully explained step-by step solutions
*       Review built into each lesson to ensure mastery
*       Chapter tests and a final exam allow students to measure progress
*       Dramatically Improves Test Scores!

UNCONDITIONAL GUARANTEE

Use Rick Fisher's Mastering Essential Math Skills for 20 minutes a day as directed. If you don't see what you feel are dramatically improved math test scores, send us a note saying so. You'll receive a prompt, complete refund - no questions asked!

THERE IS NO RISK!

Our Experience:

I simply can’t say enough good things about this program!  My 12-year old son, Hayden, totally bombed Algebra I using another program last year and had planned to repeat it this year.  Right off the bat, we both noticed that No-Nonsense Algebra’s video instruction was more concise, easy to understand, and had a very conversational tone that kept your interest.  Often times, this type of instruction can be monotone and difficult to follow…high on the boring factor.  But not so with this program! 

Each morning, he has gotten up and waited eagerly to watch the online video so he could get right to his math.  Gone are the days of putting off math until the end of the day.  We both found the practice to be just enough to make sure he understood the application fully, but not so much as to become overwhelming.  He even got 100% on 3 lessons in a row!  That did wonders to restoring his confidence in his ability to do his math.  As you can see from this photo, he has a genuine smile of pride while showing off that first 100%!

It has continued to be a great success for him.  Enough so that we ditched the other program and have switched over to this program for the rest of our school year.  He even gladly used a week off to play catch-up on the lessons so it could take the place of the other program we were using.  That speaks for itself!

While he tells me that it’s getting gradually harder, he says he still feels he “gets” the material.  And each lesson offers a set of “practical tips” for understanding and applying the concept.  The tips may be simple, but truly very practical and useful for the student.  One such tip early on was to determine the sign of the answer and write it down before working on the actual computation of an equation with integers.  This happened to be something my son overlooked often that led him to get his answers incorrect.  Marking the sign before doing the computation ensured that he didn’t forget this important step.  It really helped him!

I have already recommended No-Nonsense Algebra to a number of friends who have students struggling with Algebra, including both homeschooled and public-schooled children. 

I can’t honestly think of any negatives to this program.  Its concise but effective layout never devotes more than 2 pages to any given lesson, which in itself appears less daunting to the student before they even begin.  Every lesson includes just a few review problems from previous lessons to ensure mastery and retention.  I did notice one error in the answer key…for lesson 1.7, question 5, the answer should be 625, not 225.  I contacted the company about this error, and they assured me that this was the first printing of the program, and any errors would be corrected in subsequent printings.  Our communication was a positive experience, and the error was duly noted for correction.

The only thing I’d like to suggest to the vendor is to make the answer key a separate document instead of including the answers in the back of the student’s workbook.  I’m ashamed to admit that Hayden was so frustrated with Algebra I last year that he was caught cheating a couple of times.  I’d rather not provide the temptation by having the answer key at his fingertips.  My concern prompted me to separate the answer pages from the rest of his book and make them inaccessible to him.  Beyond that, though, I can’t think of anything I’d change about this program!  It’s literally a success story waiting to happen!  I’d recommend it for children and adults alike!

You can read more about the program on the vendor’s website at http://www.mathessentials.net/algebra.html.   No-Nonsense Algebra includes an unconditional money-back guarantee if you don’t find dramatic improvement in your student’s test scores after using the product as directed for 20 minutes/day.  There is no risk involved!  You just can’t go wrong with a guarantee like that!


 The Geometry Workbook:

Now let me tell you about the supplemental Geometry workbook. 
This product is intended to be supplemental practice.  There is no online or DVD instruction available for this product.  It’s priced at $11.95.

From the Website:

This book will provide students with all the essential geometry skills. Vocabulary, points, lines, planes, perimeter, area, volume, and the Pythagorean theorem are just some of the topics that are covered. There is plenty of practical, real-life problem solving that shows students the importance of geometry in the real world.

You can view the table of contents here.  You can view sample lessons here

Our Experience:

This is a super thin workbook containing 29 lessons plus final review and tests with answer keys printed in the back of the book.  The "helpful hints" section of each lesson is essentially a couple of lines of extremely concise instruction and examples.  This is the only included instruction, and this is why I would say this book is supplementary material only.  It addresses the heart of the concept very briefly with no video instruction and no additional written instruction beyond that tiny "helpful hints" section.  These are generally 1-page lessons.  While the workbook addresses the essential geometry concepts, it certainly isn't enough material to be used for a high school credit by any means.  However, it is great practice in geometry.  My plans for this product are to schedule it in at the end of our school year when we've completed No-Nonsense Algebra, as there will be sufficient weeks remaining in our schedule to complete this workbook, as well.  Personally, I'd like to see a year or a semester of Geometry material offered with accompanying video instruction like with the algebra program, but that's probably because we were so spoiled by the excellent instruction included with the algebra!

Read more of the Crew reviews of these and other great products from Math Essentials by clicking the banner below:

Photobucket
 
Math Essentials provided me with these products free of charge for review purposes, but all opinions expressed are my own and reflect my family’s honest use of these products.

9 comments:

  1. I plan on removing the answer key pages from the back of the algebra book too! I wanted to wait until we were sure we were keeping the book first. LOL

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I've never met a teacher who handed answer keys to their students! I think that was the one big oversight in the design of this product.

      Delete
  2. Isn't this such an awesome program for Algebra!!! Soooooo cooool! I loved it too! Follow my blog too if you will!!! Following yours now! :-)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm totally excited about this! My son did Saxon Algebra I last year and totally bombed. I even paid for the Saxon Teacher DVD's (big $$ investment), but he didn't use them because they were slow and boring. I have to admit the monotone voice was a big snore factor! LOL. He was excited to be able to repeat Algebra I this year using THIS product instead. He is doing much better, and the practice isn't so overwhelmingly long. It seems to be just right! I wish there were chapter tests included, but I think I'll use the Chapter Reviews as tests for grading purposes. I'm using it for high school credit, so I need something to grade besides the lessons! :) I'm loving it, though. I love the video instruction...it's so conversational and interesting. My son doesn't complain at all. I sure wish Rick would come out with more high school math! I'd sure buy it in a heartbeat!

      Delete
  3. So now that you have hopefully used it even longer do you still love it? I am looking for a pre algebra curriculum and wondering what you thought about the algebra one?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I do still love it! I would highly recommend this line of products.

      Delete
  4. Yes, my son is still loving it! He has zero complaints about algebra this year, vs. tears and totally bombing with Saxon last year. He says he truly gets it and enjoys the video instruction. He has had little to no questions so far, and we have completed 14 weeks of school already. I truly wish they offered more higher math products, because I'd buy them in a heartbeat. Now I'm faced with trying something else for next year, and I have no idea what. I'm hoping I'll get lucky with another product review for Geometry for next school year. Keeping my fingers crossed! But I'd definitely recommend this product to everyone I know. I can't say enough good things about it. It truly works!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hello,
    Just wondering if you've figured out where you're going for Algebra 2? We are finishing Saxon Algebra 1/2 this year and my daughter likes the format, but would like more lesson problems and less review problems, this seems to fit the bill. So, my question is, since you went through Saxon Algebra 1, do you think this is a complete replacement? And my question was, where to after this? Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. He has finished this program now. I think it did wonders for his overall understanding. However, I don't think he has reached the point of MASTERY just yet. That's more about him, though, and less about the product. When he got to the end and was faced with mixed problems on the exam, he was sort of like a deer in headlights...he wasn't sure where to begin with each type of problem. If I talked him through the beginning steps, he could do it. But upon initially looking at the problem, he froze. As a result, I think he still needs to spend more time on Algebra I. But I would still highly recommend this program. If you're looking for less mixed practice and more practice on the topic at hand, then this fits the bill. Also, there is an extensive final exam at the end of the book.

      But because I don't think my son has mastered Algebra I just yet, I don't want to move him forward. I made that mistake before. So although this will be his THIRD attempt at mastering algebra, I have decided to have him do Saxon Algebra I again this next school year for 9th grade. He is 2 years older than when he first attempted it. I do have the Saxon Teacher DVD's to help him. I simply have to keep a closer check on his work as we go along. I just haven't had the time to keep a steady pulse on his progress, and it has hurt him in the long run. But he's starting high school, and I'll have to grade EVERYthing from this point on, so I'm hoping he will do better with it this time around. Part of my reason for doing Saxon again is that the spiral approach keeps him from forgetting past concepts, and he has always needed that kind of reinforcement. Another reason is that we're using the 3rd edition before Saxon was sold to Harcourt, and if you complete that edition of both Saxon Algebra I and Saxon Algebra II, Geometry is fully integrated, so it can count as 3 high school credits. The student never has to spend an entire year on Geometry alone. I already own Saxon Algebra II and the Saxcon Teacher DVD's for that, as well, so it just makes sense to give it another try. And he can get 3 math credits in 2 years this way.

      Delete